ORLY vs TYL: Head-to-Head Signal Returns (2012–2025)
How did O'Reilly Automotive (ORLY) and Tyler Technologies (TYL) fare under JumpstartSignal's 5-stage screening pipeline across our full 2012–2025 walk-forward backtest? We flagged ORLY 1 time (3 signal days, first signal in 2015) and TYL 8 times (11 signal days, first signal in 2012). Every entry price, return, and SPY comparison below is from the frozen backtest snapshot.
Head-to-Head Stats
ORLY ✅ OPPORTUNITY O'Reilly Automotive · Consumer
TYL 🏆 SPOTLIGHT Tyler Technologies · Technology
Per-Signal Returns
Each bar below shows the best return from one signal cluster, held from the entry date through Feb 1, 2026. The SPY return over the same period is shown alongside each entry, alpha is the gap between the two.
ORLY Signal Clusters
| Entry Date | Entry Price | Return | SPY Return | Alpha vs SPY |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2015 | $16.67 | +490% | +325% | +165% |
TYL Signal Clusters
| Entry Date | Entry Price | Return | SPY Return | Alpha vs SPY |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 23, 2012 | $34.38 | +974% | +567% | +407% |
| Apr 20, 2012 | $40.26 | +818% | +534% | +283% |
| Jun 22, 2012 | $39.95 | +825% | +552% | +273% |
| Aug 16, 2012 | $40.11 | +821% | +513% | +308% |
| Sep 4, 2012 | $40.73 | +807% | +518% | +289% |
| Apr 25, 2013 | $62.63 | +490% | +440% | +50% |
| Jun 3, 2013 | $69.62 | +431% | +421% | +10% |
| Jul 8, 2013 | $72.02 | +413% | +419% | -6% |
What This Teaches
You can admire a stock and still never get a trade on it. TYL: 8 signal clusters across our backtest. ORLY: 1. The screener doesn't know which is the 'better' company; it just rewards whichever chart keeps producing the entries our weights favour. Publishing both the hits and the misses is how we keep the methodology honest.
Compare More
Get signals like these delivered daily
Free daily signals from the same 5-stage pipeline that flagged these entries.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.
FAQ
Is ORLY or TYL a better momentum stock?
In our 14-year backtest, ORLY had an average alpha of +165% per signal versus +202% for TYL. ORLY produced 1 SPOTLIGHT or OPPORTUNITY buy-signal cluster vs 8 SPOTLIGHT or OPPORTUNITY buy-signal clusters for TYL.
When did JumpstartSignal first flag ORLY?
Sep 30, 2015 at an entry price of $16.67 (SPOTLIGHT or OPPORTUNITY buy signal). That signal has returned +490% held to the snapshot date, versus +325% for SPY over the same period.
When did JumpstartSignal first flag TYL?
Jan 23, 2012 at an entry price of $34.38 (SPOTLIGHT or OPPORTUNITY buy signal). That signal has returned +974% held to the snapshot date, versus +567% for SPY.
Does this mean one stock is a buy and the other isn't?
No. Historical signal frequency and past returns are not buy recommendations. Our pipeline identifies entries that would have matched the template historically. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Use these pages as methodology research, not investment advice.
Where does the underlying data come from?
All entries on this page come from the R27 walk-forward validated backtest covering 2012–2025 (the 'seo_active' snapshot in our golden archive). Entry prices, returns, and SPY comparisons are computed from Stooq end-of-day OHLCV and frozen at snapshot time. See our methodology for details.